So glad our GPS brought us to this one of a kind grill and tavern. From the outside you'd never know the hidden gem waiting inside. Staff were great, the menu was outstanding, so hard to pick just one entree. Great cocktails, huge beer offering. I had the blueberry martini, delicious! Then ordered the club sandwich on sourdough bread with Frites. My husband had the Reuben sandwich and all was delicious. Can't wait for another trip that directions so I can stop again.
This is a small place off the beaten path that serves delicious food. A little pricey but worth it. Great microbrew selection. It has a real cool outdoor seating area. I had raw oysters that were very fresh and enormous. Like I said it was a little pricey to me but I did not feel bad paying it for the quality and quantity of food and the service was great. It had a great mixed crowd of people(older, young, hip, and traditional and blue collar).
This is my go-to place to get great food and when entertaining guests from out of town! Yes, its a little more pricey compared to a lot of places in the area ($20 average for one dinner) but you get what you pay for. I've NEVER had a bad meal in all the many times I've eaten here. The 5 Hour Pot Roast is AMAZING, and that's coming from someone who would normally never order a "home cooked meal" type of item at a restaurant, but my daughter got it once and I tasted it, now it's my favorite item! The waitstaff is usually really good. They have a decent sized patio that increases their seating to probably twice the size during the warmer months. (It's surrounded by woods though, so bring mosquito repellent!) I highly, highly recommend Bartlett's !
Went with my boyfriend. around 3 pm so we had the lunch menu to choose from. Appetizers good. mussels for him...and loaded chips. We both had the Haddock and fries. I could smell the fishy smell when the waitress was about 10 feet away. My boyfriend agreed. We both tasted the fish and it was very fishy tasting. Haddock should be mild, not with a strong fish taste. The 'tartar sauce' that they serve is made with a large amt of brown grainy mustard and tasted awful. The waitress asked if I wanted anything else, so I chose the Cobb Salad with blue cheese on the side. The salad arrived with a large amount of chopped romaine lettuce, the requisite cherry/grape tomatoes, red onion, and I believe sliced zucchini. Also had 1 (one) halved hard-boiled egg, a small amt of bacon and possibly one small slice of a 'smoked turkey' product. Ranch dressing, not good very sweet. No blue cheese, anywhere.
Not great, but not bad either. Atmosphere is decent. It's a small place, so it fills up quick. I'm only giving it 4 stars because I tried it once, so maybe my review will change on my 2nd trip. I tried the fish & chips, and for over $15 I was disappointed. 2 pieces of breaded fish with plain French fries. The fish wasn't bad, but I'm pretty sure the fries came frozen in a bag. They sure didn't taste fresh or crispy, and it was about 60% of the entire meal. So if you order the fish & chips. Expect a lot of tasteless French fries.
Service was good though. So no negatives there.
Bartlett S Gourmet Grill Tavern is a US Bar based in Beverly Shores, Indiana. Bartlett S Gourmet Grill Tavern is located at 131 East Dunes Highway, Beverly Shores, IN 46301, USA.
Please contact with Bartlett S Gourmet Grill Tavern using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Bartlett S Gourmet Grill Tavern opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.